Vintage Film Review: Carefree (1938)

Another film featuring “the psychiatrist with questionable ethics’ trope, this screwball comedy, directed by Mark Sandwich, is enjoyable, but very much of its time. It’s probably foolhardy to push modern values onto a vintage musical, so putting aside the plot’s ridiculousness, it’s an enjoyable froth, a yummy confection.

Doctor Tony Flagg may have some red flags about him, but man, you gotta see him tap- dance. What a guy! What a swell. For Dr Flagg is portrayed by the debonair Mr Fred Astaire. He’s a doctor with some questionable ideas about “dames” and their silly, romantic ideals. Who should sashay into his office, but marriage- shy Amanda (Ginger Rogers) and …wow. What a gal! What a peach.

This is where the plot goes- inevitably -cuckoo bananas. He can fix this relationship, see, by inducing dream-states. He’s a strict Freudian (when are they not?) So he tries putting her on a bizarre diet: lobster with mayonnaise, seafood platter with whipped cream and for dessert, some strawberry shortcake. Rather than making her vomit though- whaddya know!- the broad has a romantic dream. But it’s not of her somewhat underwritten fiance Stephen (Ralph Bellamy, doing the best he can with the silliness) it’s of him,Tony, the good doctor. Ah, nuts!

Time to go to Plan B. He puts her under general anaesthetic (ethics, schmethics) and tries to hypnotise her into falling in love with insipid Stephen again. What could…err. possibly go wrong? Of course it descends into farce, but the whole thing is tempered by Irving Berlin numbers. They’re the cherry on the top.

Rogers is by far the focal point,here, with excellent comic timing, a sweet singing voice, and a relish for the sassiness. Amanda is a radio performer, after all, and suffice to say, after some of her wayward shenanigans under hypnosis , the sponsors won’t be back.

But the vague nod to ‘A Midsummer Night’s Dream’ keeps the rolling chaos fun. And Fred and Ginger’s elegant dance routines are, as always, evergreen bliss. I was reminded once more of Katherine Hepburn’s quote: “Fred gave Ginger class, but Ginger gave Fred sex appeal”. Yup.

Published by loreleiirvine

I'm a freelance arts critic, working with a particular emphasis on music, theatre and dance.Ageing goth, underwhelmist.

Leave a Reply